With Integrity, you have nothing to fear because you have nothing to hide.” Zig Ziglar

Integrity Pro Main Logo


Asphalt Shingles vs. Metal Roofing For Homes In Columbia, MD

3 tab asphalt shingles

Choosing The Right Roof: A Decision Above

3 tab asphalt shingles

Ever find yourself staring at your roof and wondering if it’s time for an upgrade? Or are you maybe in the process of building your dream home and can’t decide on the best roofing material?

In this post, we’ll dive deep into the pros and cons of asphalt shingles vs. metal roofing, from their lifespan and maintenance needs to their energy efficiency and environmental impact.

By the end, you’ll know exactly which roof is right for your roofing project in Columbia, MD, and the benefits of making the right choice could save you time, money, and a whole lot of stress down the line.

Asphalt Shingles vs. Metal Roofing

FeatureMetal RoofingAsphalt Shingles
DurabilityHigh: Resists extreme weather, fire, and pests.Moderate: Susceptible to high winds and extreme weather.
Lifespan40-70 years20-30 years
MaintenanceLow: Requires minimal upkeep.High: Needs regular inspection and repairs.
Energy EfficiencyExcellent: Reflects solar heat, reducing cooling costs.Good: Certain products offer reflective properties.
Environmental ImpactEco-friendly: Mostly made of recycled materials, fully recyclable.Less eco-friendly: Recycling options limited, made from petroleum products.
InstallationSpecialized: Requires professional installation.Easier: Can be installed by most roofing contractors.
CostHigher initial cost but cost-effective over time.Lower initial cost but may incur more maintenance costs.
Aesthetic VarietyWide range: Available in various styles and colors.Versatile: Offers many colors and styles.

Durability And Longevity

Close up of metal roofing tiles

When it comes to roofing in Columbia, MD, two factors stand out: durability and longevity. Whether you’re near the serene waters of Lake Elkhorn or tucked away in the peaceful suburbs, knowing how your roof will stand the test of time is crucial.

Metal Roofing

A metal roof shines in durability and longevity.

Capable of withstanding the brunt of Maryland’s diverse weather—from summer heatwaves to winter snowstorms—metal roofs offer unparalleled resistance to extreme weather.

With a lifespan that can exceed 50 years and minimal need for regular maintenance, it’s a long-term investment that pays off.

However, the higher cost and installation challenges can be a hurdle for some homeowners.

Asphalt Shingles

The traditional asphalt shingle roof is beloved for its cost-effectiveness and ease of repair.

In Columbia’s fluctuating climate, asphalt shingles typically provide a reliable cover for 20 to 30 years, though they demand more maintenance than their metal counterparts.

Despite their susceptibility to high winds and heat, advancements in architectural asphalt roof shingles offer improved durability and a touch of curb appeal.

Energy Efficiency And Environmental Impact

Energy conservation and sustainability are increasingly important for Columbia, MD, residents, particularly in communities like Hickory Ridge. Let’s compare to see which is better when it comes to a metal or asphalt roof.

Metal Roofs

Metal roofing leads the way in energy efficiency.

Its ability to reflect heat significantly lowers energy costs during Columbia’s humid summers.

Additionally, metal is often praised for its eco-friendliness; most materials, including aluminum, are recyclable, aligning with our city’s green initiatives.

For homes equipped with solar panels, metal roofs typically enhance energy savings and sustainability.

Asphalt Shingles

While asphalt shingles may lag behind metal in energy efficiency, they’re catching up.

Certain asphalt shingle products now feature energy-efficient designs that help reflect sunlight, reducing cooling needs.

Yet, the environmental impact of asphalt, a petroleum-based product, remains a concern.

Though less recyclable than metal, the introduction of architectural shingles offers slightly better durability and wind resistance.

Aesthetics And Home Value

Architectural shingles on a roof

In the charming neighborhood of River Hill, Columbia, MD, homeowners take pride in their property’s appearance and value. When it comes to selecting roofing materials, the choice between metal roofing and asphalt shingles can significantly impact both.

Metal Roofing

Metal roofs offer a modern and sleek appearance that can boost your home’s curb appeal.

With a variety of styles and colors, from traditional looks that mimic asphalt shingles to contemporary designs, metal roofing adapts to any architectural style, enhancing the aesthetic and resale value of homes in Columbia, MD.

Metal’s durability and longevity also appeal to potential buyers, making it a wise investment for most homeowners.

Asphalt Shingles

Asphalt shingle roofs are a timeless choice that offers versatility and classic beauty.

Available in a wide range of colors and styles, including three-tab shingles and architectural asphalt shingles, they can complement any home design.

While asphalt shingles may not have the same modern appeal as metal roofs, they still offer significant curb appeal and can increase the resale value of a home, especially when well-maintained.

Installation And Cost Considerations

Choosing the right roofing material for your Columbia, MD, home in the Kings Contrivance area involves understanding the installation process and cost considerations associated with metal roofs and asphalt shingles.

Metal Roofing

The metal roof cost is typically higher initially than asphalt shingles, with prices varying by material (e.g., aluminum, steel).

The installation of metal roofing is more complex, requiring specialized skills and tools, which can drive up labor costs.

However, the longer lifespan and less maintenance required for metal roofs can make them more cost-effective in the long run.

Discover the cost of installing and replacing roofs in Maryland.

Asphalt Shingles

Asphalt shingle roofing is known for its affordability and ease of installation, making it a cost-effective option for many homeowners.

Any skilled roofing contractor can easily install asphalt roofing, reducing labor costs.

While asphalt roofs may require more maintenance over time, their lower initial cost makes them an attractive option for those on a budget.

Here’s how to install a roof.

Maintenance And Repair

Metal standing seam roof on a residential home

Metal Roofing

Metal roofs boast a low-maintenance profile, with periodic inspections and gutter cleanings being the primary upkeep activities.

While they’re resilient, should a repair be needed, it might require specialized skills.

However, the incidence of repairs is significantly lower compared to other materials, contributing to a longer lifespan with minimal upkeep.

Asphalt Shingles

The maintenance of asphalt shingle roofs involves regular inspections to replace damaged or missing shingles, especially after severe weather events.

The ease of repairing or replacing shingles makes it a less daunting task for homeowners.

Proactive maintenance can significantly extend the life of an asphalt shingle roof, ensuring it remains protective and attractive for years.


Metal Roofing

Metal roofs often come with longer warranties, reflecting their longer lifespan and durability.

These warranties can cover everything from material defects to the finish, offering homeowners peace of mind in their investment.

It’s important to understand the specific terms and conditions, as they can vary by manufacturer.

Asphalt Shingles

Asphalt shingle warranties can vary significantly, from basic coverage to extended warranties that cover more extensive scenarios.

While the lifespan of asphalt shingles is shorter than metal choosing high-quality shingles and proper installation can maximize their life and ensure warranty protection.

Climate Adaptability

Home with a metal roof

Metal Roofing

Metal roofs excel in handling Columbia’s varied climate, from hot, humid summers to cold, snowy winters.

Their superior durability means they’re less likely to sustain damage from heavy snowfall or high winds, making them an ideal choice for the region’s seasonal extremes.

The reflective properties of metal also help in keeping homes cooler during the summer months, adding a layer of thermal efficiency.

Asphalt Shingles

Asphalt shingles are well-suited to Columbia’s climate but may require more frequent inspections and maintenance to address potential weather-related damages, such as from wind or ice dams.

However, modern advancements in asphalt shingle technology have improved their resilience, offering options designed for enhanced wind resistance and temperature adaptability, making them a viable option for homeowners.

Pros And Cons

Integrity Home Pro team installing a metal roof

When weighing the options between metal roofing and asphalt shingles for your home in Columbia, MD, it’s essential to consider the pros and cons of each roofing material. Let’s break it down to help you make an informed decision.

Metal Roofing


  • Longer lifespan: Can last 40 to 70 years with little maintenance.
  • Durability: Resistant to high winds, fire, and extreme weather conditions.
  • Energy efficiency: Reflects solar heat, reducing energy costs.
  • Eco-friendliness: Mostly made of recycled materials and fully recyclable.


  • Higher initial cost: More expensive than asphalt shingles both in material and installation.
  • Noise: Can be noisier during rain or hail without proper insulation.
  • Installation: Requires specialized contractors for installation.

Asphalt Shingles


  • Cost-effective: Lower initial cost and easier to install, making them a cost-effective option.
  • Versatility: Wide variety of colors and styles, offering flexibility in aesthetics.
  • Ease of repair: Damaged shingles can be easily replaced.


  • Shorter lifespan: Typically lasts 20 to 30 years with more maintenance required.
  • Susceptibility to weather: More prone to damage from high winds and extreme weather.
  • Less energy-efficient: Absorbs more heat, potentially increasing energy costs.

Integrity Home Pro: Elevating Roofs, Exceeding Expectations

At Integrity Home Pro, we understand that your home is your sanctuary, and its roof is the crown that protects it. Whether you’re leaning toward the sleek durability of metal roofing or the classic charm of asphalt shingles, our team has the expertise to bring your vision to life.

Ready to take the first step towards a roof that combines aesthetics with resilience? Fill out our contact form today or give us a call, and let Integrity Home Pro elevate your home’s protection and style to new heights.

Share the Post:

Your Experience Is Important

Please read our reviews to learn why our clients love working with us!

Paul ChristensenPaul Christensen
17:25 18 Sep 23
I found this company is consistently capable, honest, and efficient. And they stand behind their work. My roof and gutter repair went very smoothly.
Stephanie CramerStephanie Cramer
21:48 16 Sep 23
I always contact Integrity for all of my major projects! They are reliable, have great project teams, and always do an outstanding job!
Steven WeberSteven Weber
16:29 07 Sep 23
Bathroom remodel exceeded expectations. Raul performed the work as if it was his own bathroom. His attention to detail was exceptional!If you want a quality job done right, choose Integrity Home Pro!
Anthony BynumAnthony Bynum
01:48 22 Aug 23
Recently we hired Integrity Pro to design and complete a combination bathroom and Laundry room in our basement.We knew for quite sometime this would be a big time consuming job. We actually interview at least 6 other construction companies. We found out that a lot of plumbers were not interested in the construction aspects of this type of work. We found out that anyone offering to do this for 7-8 thousand dollars was not trustworthy.More than once we were ready to pull the trigger only to walk back from the ledge for different reasons.The first thing that stood out on the Integrity estimate was that big fat liability policy that was part of the estimate proposal. As a retired Casualty Insurance Professional this was definitely a determining factor. The other was the fixture allowance.But it did take 2-3 conversations to lead to the big hand shake.Then the next “feel good” factor was Alberto the lead carpenter. He came in on a Saturday after the plumber because he needed to get a jump on things. He worked every Saturday until finished.We saw Mike the Project Manager like 4 times. Very reassuring.The door to the laundry room needed some creative thinking. Once again great results.For us this was a once in a life time project, we had much to loose if done incorrectly, but much to gain when done right. That is where we are, on the plus side. Well done.Anthony Bynum
Valerie MartinValerie Martin
17:21 21 Aug 23
As always excellent!
Tammy BrownTammy Brown
00:16 13 Aug 23
This company is very responsive. Not only did Danny (owner) listen to our concerns, but he heard our concerns. Many days, I was leaving as the workers arrived. Danny would leave post it notes to ensure the contractors addressed any concerns from the day before. The contractors are very respectful of our home. They cleaned up every afternoon so as not to leave our house in disarray.My fireplace turned out beautifully. My bathroom doors were moved and the new locking barn darns turned out beautifully. Danny is having a custom threshold designed to make the transition between too rooms seamless. Danny took a load barring wall down to open up the kitchen and the back room. Danny ensured the openings to these rooms were at least 36 inches. Ensuring the house is ADA accessible was very important to me.
Lynn KellnerLynn Kellner
16:11 08 Aug 23
Our project coordinator on site was Alberto. He was so fastidious, and was so committed to making the job look fantastic at the end. He even came back after he realized he forgot to put some thing on our final cabinet installation even thought he was in his truck, on his way out. He was just so excellent and we can’t have asked for a better project result.
Crystal LemieuxCrystal Lemieux
01:57 14 Jul 23
I’m so happy to have found Integrity Home Pro! After working with multiple contractors on various house projects, Integrity Home Pro has been a breath of fresh air. They’re professional, courteous, knowledgeable, reliable, show up when they say they’re going to, and are quick to respond to phone calls and emails. Not only that, their work is excellent. We hired them to renovate a bathroom and were so impressed we hired them to renovate our sunroom and kitchen and make various improvements around the outside of our home. I cannot recommend them highly enough and will work with them again for any future home improvements.
Philip CoynePhilip Coyne
19:28 04 Feb 23
My wife and I reached out to Integrity Home Pro for a quote to repair/replace wood under our bay windows that started rotting years ago. Within a few days, we had an estimate with several different options, and reasonable price set for the work done, as well as an estimate for how long the work would take.Within 3 weeks, Integrity Home Pro sent out their team to replace our rotted wood with panels and had finished the work within the time originally estimated. We're so happy with the work they've done, that we will certainly be reaching out again for more work on our home.Long and short: Integrity Home Pro has shown us professional courtesy, impressive workmanship, and genuine care for our needs. The quality of service is a rarity, and we plan on reaching out to Integrity again in the near future.Photos provided to show the before and after
K MalindaK Malinda
18:51 06 Jan 23
Integrity Home Pro was a pleasure to work with. I had extensive hail damage to my house and the process of getting information to my insurance and approval for a full replacement was a long process. Ben at Integrity was very patient and extremely helpful every step of the way. He assisted with everything the insurance needed so that now I have a new roof and siding. The installers were outstanding and when they were finished you could not see any debris on the lawn or damage to any bushes. I used Integrity about 10 years ago for the previous roof that the hail damaged ( I thought they were terrific then) and I think they only have improved with time. I highly recommend them!
Monica BriggsMonica Briggs
15:51 06 Oct 22
Integrity Home Pro did an excellent job at remodeling our bathroom. They are very skilled, professional, and they work together to get the job done in a timely fashion. They were very patient, attentive, and courteous, and always kept us abreast every step of the way. Our newly remodeled bathroom exceeds our expectations and is simply beautiful. We could not have asked for a more dedicated and devoted team.
Kerry WesterveltKerry Westervelt
16:33 20 Aug 22
Integrity Home Pro were very pleasant and easy to work with when our roof was damaged by a tree branch. They replaced my roof quickly in the morning. Also, I am a returning customer knowing they did a great job replacing my roof 20 years ago.
Jeanne BeansJeanne Beans
07:42 08 Mar 22
Integrity Home-Pro just completed remolding our kitchen. The process took two weeks. Elmer Lopez did the work. He worked non-stop everyday; his workmanship is premium. Tera Ingwersen guided us through the process from the office on a regular basis and was always available to answer questions. Integrity's quote for the work was significantly less than a quote given by another company. Integrity's owner, Danny Peterson, personally came when we called about getting a quote. He followed up on two occasions as the work was being done. Integrity Home Pro has done other major projects on our home and we have been pleased each time.

Reimagine Your Home And Experience Elevated Living In The Greater DC Area